Small Business Accounting Software Comparison: Xero vs MYOB Australia 2025 | Complete Guide
Published: April 2025
Introduction
Choosing the right accounting software is one of the most critical decisions for Australian small and medium businesses. With Xero now commanding over 60% of the online accounting software market in Australia, while MYOB holds around 20-25%, the competition between these two platforms has never been more intense.
This comprehensive comparison will examine every aspect of both platforms, from basic functionality to advanced features, helping you make an informed decision that could save your business thousands of dollars and countless hours annually.
Both Xero and MYOB offer cloud-based solutions designed specifically for Australian businesses, but they take fundamentally different approaches to accounting software design, pricing, and user experience. Understanding these differences is crucial for selecting the platform that will best serve your business needs both now and as you grow.
Market Position and Popularity
The Australian accounting software landscape has undergone a dramatic transformation over the past decade. A decade ago, MYOB was dominant with over 80% market share, but Xero has experienced tremendous growth since launching in Australia in 2010.
Current Market Share:
Xero: 60%+ market share
MYOB: 20-25% market share
Other providers: 15-20% combined
Regarding online engagement, Xero captures a substantial 55.14% click share, followed by MYOB at 17.15%, demonstrating Xero's strong digital presence and user preference.
This market dominance isn't just about marketing – it reflects real user preferences based on functionality, ease of use, and business outcomes.
MYOB: MYOB offers significantly stronger inventory capabilities, particularly in its AccountRight platform. Features like multi-location tracking, advanced inventory reporting, and complex inventory
Winner: MYOB (superior inventory functionality)
User Experience and Interface
Xero Advantages:
Intuitive, modern interface design
Mobile-first approach
Excellent onboarding process
Streamlined navigation
MYOB Advantages:
Familiar desktop-like interface
Comprehensive feature access
Detailed customisation options
Traditional accounting workflow
Winner: Xero (superior user experience and learning curve)
Integration Capabilities
Xero Integrations:
Xero offers a slight edge with automatic GST calculations and the ability to connect to over 1000 apps
Popular integrations: PayPal, Stripe, Shopify, WooCommerce
Results: Reduced manual data entry by 85% and improved accuracy.
Industry-Specific Considerations
Retail and E-commerce
Xero Advantages:
Extensive e-commerce integrations
Automated inventory sync
Multi-channel sales tracking
Payment gateway integration
MYOB Advantages:
Advanced inventory management
Point-of-sale integration
Multi-location tracking
Detailed product reporting
Recommendation: Xero for online retail, MYOB for multi-location physical retail
Professional Services
Xero Advantages:
Simple time tracking
Project profitability analysis
Client invoicing automation
Expense management
MYOB Advantages:
Comprehensive time tracking
Job costing capabilities
Client management features
Detailed project reporting
Recommendation: Xero for simplicity, MYOB for detailed project management
Manufacturing and Distribution
Xero Advantages:
Basic inventory tracking
Simple manufacturing workflows
Cost-effective solution
Good integration options
MYOB Advantages:
Advanced inventory management
Manufacturing modules
Multi-location tracking
Complex costing capabilities
Recommendation: MYOB for complex manufacturing, Xero for simple assembly
Making the Right Choice: Decision Framework
Choose Xero If:
Business Characteristics:
Small to medium business (under 50 employees)
Primarily service-based or simple retail
Growth-focused with scaling plans
Technology-savvy team
Budget-conscious
Extensive integration needs
Specific Situations:
Starting a new business
Switching from manual processes
Need mobile accessibility
Require extensive third-party integrations
Want automatic bank reconciliation
Prefer modern, intuitive interfaces
Choose MYOB If:
Business Characteristics:
Established business with complex needs
Manufacturing or complex inventory requirements
Multiple locations or divisions
Traditional accounting preferences
Need comprehensive payroll features
Require phone support
Specific Situations:
Complex inventory management needs
Detailed project tracking requirements
Multi-location operations
Established workflows and processes
Need extensive customisation
Prefer local support and training
Cost-Benefit Analysis
Total Cost of Ownership Analysis
Xero Standard Plan (3-Year Analysis):
Software cost: $1,332 (3 years)
Setup and training: $500
Additional integrations: $600
Total 3-year cost: $2,432
MYOB Business Plan (3-Year Analysis):
Software cost: $2,052 (3 years)
Setup and training: $800
Additional features: $400
Total 3-year cost: $3,252
3-Year Savings with Xero: $820
Return on Investment Analysis
Xero Benefits:
Time savings: 10-15 hours per month
Reduced errors: 90% improvement in accuracy
Faster invoicing: 50% reduction in collection time
Automated processes: 70% reduction in manual tasks
MYOB Benefits:
Comprehensive reporting: Better decision-making
Inventory management: Reduced stock losses
Project tracking: Improved profitability
Local support: Reduced downtime
Average Payback Timeline:
Xero: 3-6 months (through time savings and automation)
MYOB: 6-12 months (through comprehensive features and reporting)
Implementation Timeline Comparison
Implementation and Migration
Xero Implementation
Timeline: 1-2 weeksSteps:
Data migration from existing system
Chart of accounts setup
Bank feed configuration
Integration setup
Team training
Go-live and support
Migration Support:
Free migration tools
Video tutorials
Email support
Community forums
MYOB Implementation
Timeline: 2-4 weeksSteps:
Comprehensive data migration
System configuration
User training
Custom report setup
Integration configuration
Go-live and ongoing support
Migration Support:
Professional migration services
Phone support
On-site training available
Dedicated account management
Future-Proofing Your Choice
Technology Trends
Xero Innovation:
AI-powered features
Machine learning for categorisation
Advanced analytics
Open API development
Mobile-first approach
MYOB Innovation:
Business intelligence tools
Advanced reporting
Industry-specific solutions
Cloud platform expansion
Integration improvements
Market Direction
Xero is generally preferred by smaller businesses due to its ease of use and low cost of entry, while MYOB maintains strength in more complex business environments.
Xero's Growth Strategy:
Expanding integration ecosystem
Enhanced mobile capabilities
AI and automation features
Global market expansion
SME-focused innovation
MYOB's Growth Strategy:
Comprehensive business solutions
Industry-specific features
Local market expertise
Enterprise-level capabilities
Traditional business focus
Common Mistakes to Avoid
1. Choosing Based on Price Alone
The Problem: Selecting the cheapest option without considering feature requirements and long-term costs.
The Solution: Evaluate total cost of ownership including time savings, error reduction, and productivity gains.
2. Ignoring Integration Needs
The Problem: Not considering how the accounting software will connect with existing business systems.
The Solution: Map out all required integrations before making a decision.
3. Underestimating Training Requirements
The Problem: Assuming all team members will quickly adapt to new software.
The Solution: Factor in training time and costs for all users.
4. Not Planning for Growth
The Problem: Choosing software that meets current needs but can't scale with business growth.
The Solution: Consider where your business will be in 2-3 years and choose accordingly.
Expert Recommendations
For Startups and Small Businesses
Recommendation: Xero Standard Plan ($37/month)
Reasons:
Cost-effective solution
Easy to learn and implement
Excellent integration options
Strong mobile capabilities
Automatic features reduce manual work
For Established Medium Businesses
Recommendation: Depends on complexity
Simple operations: Xero Premium ($70/month)
Complex operations: MYOB Advanced ($69/month)
For Specific Industries
E-commerce: Xero (superior integrations)
Manufacturing: MYOB (better inventory management)
Professional Services: Xero (simplicity and efficiency)
After comprehensive analysis, Xero emerges as the superior choice for most Australian small and medium businesses. Here's why:
Market Leadership: Xero now has over 60% of the online accounting software market, reflecting real user preferences and satisfaction.
Cost Effectiveness: Xero offers better value across most business sizes, with significant cost savings particularly for small businesses.
User Experience: Xero's modern, intuitive interface reduces learning time and increases user adoption.
Integration Ecosystem: Xero offers a slight edge with automatic GST calculations and the ability to connect to over 1000 apps, providing unmatched flexibility.
Mobile Capabilities: Superior mobile experience enabling business management anywhere, anytime.
Automation Features: Advanced automation reduces manual work and improves accuracy.
Scalability: Excellent growth capabilities with features that scale with your business.
Australian Compliance: Full compliance with Australian tax and reporting requirements.
While MYOB remains a solid choice for businesses with complex inventory needs or those preferring traditional accounting approaches, Xero's combination of ease of use, comprehensive features, cost-effectiveness, and extensive integration capabilities makes it the clear winner for most Australian SMEs.
The numbers speak for themselves – Xero captures a substantial 55.14% click share, followed by MYOB at 17.15% – demonstrating strong market preference and user satisfaction.
For businesses ready to embrace modern, efficient accounting practices, Xero provides the perfect platform to streamline operations, reduce costs, and focus on what matters most: growing your business.
Final Comparison Summary Table
About Scale Suite
Scale Suite delivers finance and human resource services to support the growth of Australian businesses. Our Sydney-based team creates custom packages tailored to your needs, seamlessly integrating with your existing teams. From comprehensive finance services and strategic business support to recruitment and HR services, we reduce costs, save time, and help you scale confidently.
Ready to stop wasting time on finance & HR tasks and start focusing on growth?
Our business experts will assess your current setup and show you exactly how much time and money you could save with our tailored services.
No lock-in contracts. We help you choose only the services that fit your business needs and you pay for exactly what you use. Pause our services at any time.
Thank you for your interest! Your submission has been received. Our team will get back to you within 1-2 business days.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Book your free 30-minute strategy call with our experts now
