Published: January 2025

‍

Terminating an employee in Australia is a complex and highly regulated process, governed by the Fair Work Act 2009 and supported by the Fair Work Commission and Ombudsman. With unfair dismissal claims costing businesses an average of $20,000 in legal fees and settlements (Fair Work Commission, 2024), understanding the legal framework, procedural requirements, and proactive strategies is essential for minimising risks and ensuring compliance. This article provides an exploration of the termination process, including steps to follow, legal obligations, potential risks, and best practices for preventing disputes, offering Australian businesses a roadmap to navigate this sensitive area with confidence.

‍

Legal Framework and Obligations

The Fair Work Act 2009 sets out the legal requirements for terminating employees, ensuring the process is fair, transparent, and based on valid reasons. Employees who have served the minimum employment period—6 months for businesses with 15 or more employees, or 12 months for small businesses with fewer than 15 employees—are eligible to file unfair dismissal claims if the termination is deemed harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. The Small Business Fair Dismissal Code provides simplified guidelines for small businesses, requiring evidence of performance issues, misconduct, or redundancy, along with opportunities for the employee to improve.

Valid reasons for termination include:

• Poor Performance: Consistent failure to meet performance standards, such as a sales representative missing targets despite warnings and support.
• Misconduct: Actions like theft, fraud, or workplace harassment that breach company policies or legal standards.
• Redundancy: Elimination of a role due to operational changes, such as automation reducing the need for manual data entry.
• Capacity: Inability to perform inherent job requirements, such as a driver losing their licence.

Employers must provide written notice of termination (or payment in lieu) based on the employee’s length of service, ranging from 1 to 5 weeks under the National Employment Standards. Final pay must include all outstanding wages, accrued annual leave, and, in some cases, long service leave, along with superannuation contributions up to the termination date. Failure to comply with these requirements can lead to penalties of up to $16,500 for individuals and $82,500 for corporations.

‍

Steps for a Compliant Termination Process

A fair and compliant termination process involves multiple steps to ensure legal adherence and minimise disputes. These steps include:

• Identify a Valid Reason: Clearly articulate the reason for termination, supported by evidence such as performance reviews, disciplinary records, or redundancy analyses. For example, a retail manager terminating an employee for poor performance should have documented evidence of missed targets and prior warnings.
• Provide Warnings and Support: For performance-based terminations, issue formal warnings and offer support, such as training or mentoring, to address deficiencies. The Fair Work Act requires employees be given a reasonable opportunity to improve, typically through a performance improvement plan (PIP).
• Conduct a Fair Process: Allow the employee to respond to allegations, particularly in cases of misconduct. For instance, an employee accused of theft should be given a chance to explain their actions in a formal meeting, with a support person present if requested.
• Issue Written Notice: Provide written notice specifying the termination date and reason, or pay in lieu of notice. For example, an employee with 3 years of service requires 3 weeks’ notice or equivalent payment.
• Calculate Final Pay: Ensure final pay includes all entitlements, such as accrued leave and superannuation. For an employee earning $80,000 annually, final pay might include $6,153 for 4 weeks of unused annual leave, plus outstanding wages.
• Document the Process: Maintain detailed records of performance issues, warnings, meetings, and termination rationale to defend against potential claims. Documentation is critical in unfair dismissal cases, as it demonstrates procedural fairness.

‍

Risks and Challenges

Terminating an employee carries significant risks, particularly if the process is not handled carefully. Key risks include:

• Unfair Dismissal Claims: Employees can file claims with the Fair Work Commission if they believe the termination was unfair, harsh, or lacked procedural fairness. In 2024, 14,000 unfair dismissal applications were filed, with 65% resulting in settlements or reinstatement (Fair Work Commission). For example, terminating an employee without prior warnings or evidence of poor performance could lead to a successful claim.
• Discrimination Claims: Terminations based on protected attributes—such as age, gender, disability, or pregnancy—violate anti-discrimination laws, risking penalties of up to $66,600 per breach under the Australian Human Rights Commission. For instance, dismissing an employee shortly after they disclose a disability could trigger a discrimination claim unless the reason is clearly unrelated.
• Reputational Damage: Poorly managed terminations can harm a business’s reputation, particularly in tight-knit industries or local communities, leading to difficulties in attracting talent.
• Financial Costs: Beyond legal fees, businesses may face costs for severance payments, back pay, or penalties for non-compliance. A 2023 study estimated that terminations cost Australian businesses $1.2 billion annually in legal and administrative expenses (Business Australia).

‍

Proactive Strategies to Prevent Disputes

To minimise the risks associated with termination, businesses should adopt proactive measures to ensure fairness and compliance:

• Implement Clear Policies: Develop comprehensive performance and conduct policies, communicated to all employees during onboarding. For example, a policy outlining acceptable workplace behaviour can provide a basis for addressing misconduct.
• Conduct Regular Appraisals: Use performance appraisals to identify and address issues early, reducing the likelihood of sudden terminations. Regular feedback ensures employees are aware of expectations and have opportunities to improve.
• Train Managers: Provide training on termination procedures, including legal requirements and procedural fairness. Managers should understand how to document issues, issue warnings, and conduct termination meetings.
• Seek Legal Advice: Consult HR or legal professionals before terminating employees, particularly in complex cases involving misconduct or protected attributes.
• Use Performance Improvement Plans: For performance-based terminations, implement PIPs that outline specific goals, timelines, and support measures. A 2023 study found that 80% of employees on PIPs either improved or left voluntarily, reducing unfair dismissal risks (AHRI).

‍

Real-World Example

A Brisbane-based manufacturing firm decides to terminate a machine operator for consistent underperformance. The manager documents three months of missed production targets, issues two formal warnings, and implements a PIP with additional training. Despite support, the operator fails to improve, and the firm provides 2 weeks’ notice and final pay, including accrued leave. By documenting the process and following Fair Work guidelines, the firm avoids an unfair dismissal claim, demonstrating the importance of procedural fairness.

‍

Conclusion

Terminating an employee is a high-stakes process that requires meticulous adherence to the Fair Work Act, clear documentation, and a commitment to fairness. By identifying valid reasons, following a structured process, and implementing proactive measures, businesses can minimise legal and financial risks while maintaining a positive workplace reputation. Regular training, clear policies, and legal consultation are essential for navigating this complex area.

‍

Disclaimer: Termination carries significant legal risks. Consult legal and HR professionals to ensure compliance with specific circumstances.