Finance
Human Resources
Technology
Australian business

Choosing an Accounting System for Business Growth: Xero vs MYOB

Hands using a black calculator with a pen, positioned in front of an open laptop on a wooden desk. Choosing an applicable accounting system and Xero in an option for this Australian business

Published: December 2024

In Australia’s fast-paced business environment, selecting the right accounting system is critical for streamlining operations and ensuring compliance with complex regulations. A robust accounting system simplifies financial management, ensures regulatory adherence, and provides actionable insights for growth. Among the many options available, Xero and MYOB dominate the Australian market. However, Xero stands out as the superior choice for most SMEs due to its user-friendly interface, cloud-based accessibility, and comprehensive features tailored to Australian needs.

This article explores why Xero is the best accounting software for Australian SMEs, compares it to MYOB, and provides guidance for a seamless transition, with insights relevant to service sectors such as law firms, accounting firms, consulting firms, marketing agencies, public relations firms, architectural and engineering services, educational institutions, healthcare providers, and real estate companies.

Why Choosing the Right Accounting System Matters

An accounting system is the backbone of a business’s financial health, enabling accurate tracking of income, expenses, taxes, and cash flow. For Australian SMEs, compliance with Goods and Services Tax (GST), Business Activity Statement (BAS) reporting, and Single Touch Payroll (STP) is non-negotiable. The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) reported that 28% of SMEs faced compliance penalties in 2023, averaging $5,000 per incident, often due to inaccurate or late submissions (ATO, 2023). Choosing an inefficient system can lead to errors, missed deadlines, and lost growth opportunities.

Service-based businesses face unique challenges:

  • A law firm needs to track billable hours and manage client trust accounts seamlessly.
  • A marketing agency requires flexible invoicing for project-based work.
  • A healthcare provider must handle payroll for casual staff while adhering to STP requirements.

The right software minimises these pain points, saving time and reducing errors. A 2024 Xero survey found that SMEs using cloud-based accounting software saved an average of 15 hours per week on financial tasks, boosting productivity and enabling focus on core operations.

Xero: The Best Option for Australian Businesses

Xero has become the preferred accounting software for over 1.4 million Australian and New Zealand subscribers (Xero, 2024), particularly among service-sector SMEs. Here’s why:

Ease of Use

Xero’s intuitive interface is designed for users with minimal accounting expertise. Its dashboard offers a real-time snapshot of cash flow, outstanding invoices, and expenses, making it accessible for busy business owners. For example, a real estate company can quickly review rental income and property maintenance costs without navigating complex menus. A 2023 Canstar survey rated Xero 4.8/5 for user-friendliness, reflecting its appeal across sectors.

Cloud-Based Accessibility

As a fully cloud-based platform, Xero enables access to financial data anytime, anywhere, on any device. This is invaluable for businesses with remote or hybrid teams, such as a consulting firm with staff across multiple cities or an educational institution managing finances across campuses. Xero’s mobile app supports on-the-go invoicing and expense tracking, with 85% of users reporting improved flexibility (Xero, 2024).

Integration with Australian Tax System

Xero is optimised for Australian compliance, integrating seamlessly with the ATO for GST, BAS, and STP submissions. Its STP functionality ensures payroll compliance for businesses like healthcare providers with casual nursing staff. Xero’s direct ATO lodgement feature achieves a 98% success rate for BAS submissions, reducing errors (ATO, 2023).

Automation

Xero automates repetitive tasks, such as bank reconciliations, invoicing, and payroll calculations. For instance, a public relations firm can automate recurring invoices for retainer clients, saving 5–10 hours monthly. Automation reduces human error by 30%, according to a 2023 MYOB report, enhancing accuracy for accounting firms managing client ledgers.

Third-Party Integrations

With over 1,000 integrations, Xero connects with tools like HubSpot (for marketing agencies), Shopify (for real estate companies with online listings), and Deputy (for healthcare providers managing rostering). This versatility streamlines workflows, with 70% of Xero users reporting improved operational efficiency (Xero, 2024).

Scalability

Xero’s tiered pricing plans (starting at $29/month for the Starter plan, up to $65/month for Premium) cater to businesses of all sizes. A sole-trader architect can use the Starter plan for basic invoicing, while a growing engineering firm can upgrade to Premium for multi-currency support. Xero’s scalability ensures it adapts to evolving business needs.

Comparing Xero and MYOB

MYOB, with a 40-year presence in Australia, remains a strong contender, particularly for businesses with specialised needs. However, Xero outperforms in several critical areas, making it the preferred choice for most SMEs.

Key Differences

  • User Experience: Xero’s sleek, intuitive design requires minimal training, ideal for a marketing agency onboarding new staff. In contrast, MYOB’s interface can feel dated and complex, often necessitating formal training, which may deter smaller firms like a public relations agency with limited resources.
  • Cloud Capabilities: Xero’s fully cloud-based platform offers superior accessibility and mobile functionality, enabling a real estate company to manage finances on-site during property inspections. MYOB’s hybrid model (combining desktop and cloud) is less seamless, with slower updates and limited mobile features, which can hinder a consulting firm with remote teams.
  • Integration and Automation: Xero’s ecosystem of over 1,000 integrations far surpasses MYOB’s 300+, allowing a law firm to connect with practice management tools like Clio. Xero’s advanced automation, such as automated bank feeds, saves more time than MYOB’s less robust features, benefiting accounting firms handling high-volume transactions.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Xero’s pricing, starting at $29/month, is competitive, with transparent tiers. MYOB’s plans, starting at $30/month, can escalate to $100+/month for advanced features, making Xero more affordable for SMEs like an educational institution managing tight budgets (Canstar, 2024).

When MYOB Shines

MYOB excels in niche areas, such as job costing for architectural firms tracking project expenses or inventory management for engineering services with physical assets. Businesses with these specific requirements may find MYOB’s specialised modules more suitable, though they come at a higher cost and complexity.

For most service-sector SMEs, Xero’s versatility, ease of use, and cost-effectiveness make it the better fit, particularly for businesses prioritising compliance and scalability.

Making the Transition to Xero

Switching to Xero is straightforward, with robust support to ease the process. Xero offers:

  • Step-by-Step Guides: Online tutorials and migration tools simplify data transfer from MYOB, QuickBooks, or spreadsheets.
  • Certified Advisors: Over 10,000 Xero-certified accountants and bookkeepers in Australia assist with setup (Xero, 2024). For example, a law firm can leverage advisors such as Scale Suite to migrate client data seamlessly.
  • Customer Support: 24/7 support via phone, email, or live chat ensures quick resolution of issues.
  • Free Trial: A 30-day free trial allows businesses like public relations firms to test features without commitment.

The transition typically takes 1–3 weeks, with initial setup costs ranging from $500–$2,000 for professional assistance, depending on business complexity. SMEs often recoup this investment within 6 months through time savings and reduced compliance errors. For instance, a healthcare provider switching to Xero reported a 40% reduction in payroll processing time after implementation (Xero, 2024).

Conclusion

For Australian SMEs seeking a user-friendly, scalable, and compliance-ready accounting solution, Xero is the clear leader. Its intuitive interface, cloud-based accessibility, seamless ATO integration, and extensive automation make it ideal for service-sector businesses—whether a law firm tracking billable hours, a healthcare provider managing payroll, or a marketing agency streamlining invoicing. While MYOB suits niche needs like job costing, Xero’s versatility and cost-effectiveness set it apart.

Investing in Xero is a strategic step towards financial efficiency and business growth. By simplifying compliance and enhancing insights, Xero empowers Australian SMEs to focus on their core operations. Explore Xero’s features with a free trial or consult a certified advisor to tailor it to your needs. With Xero, your accounting is in capable hands, paving the way for a sustainable future.

About Scale Suite

Scale Suite delivers seamless, scalable finance, human resource, and technology solutions designed for growing Australian businesses. Whether you need a custom package or pay-as-you-go support, we provide expert services that save you time, reduce costs, and enhance efficiency. With focus on speed, flexibility, and smart technology, we help businesses like yours operate smoothly and scale with confidence.

Contact us

Talk to our team.
We would love to hear from you.

We’re here to help. Fill out this form, and we will get back to you.

Thank you for your interest!
Your submission has been received. Our team will get back to you within 1-2 business days.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
"A collage of five people in circular frames: a woman smiling by a blue door, a young man in an apron, a man in a shirt near shelves, a woman with long hair in an office, and a man in profile view."

Unlock your business potential today

Book a Free Consult
"Five circular portraits of diverse individuals on a black background. The center portrait features a man with glasses, surrounded by four others, including a woman in an apron giving a thumbs up and a man on a phone."